The situation in Israel.

I’m a little sad about the current goings-on. Granted, I don’t know very much at all about the strife-filled history of Israel and Palestine, but it’s clear to me that the current state of affairs is pretty terrible. Palestinian militants kidnap a young Israeli soldier? (Almost a reduncancy, as I understand it; those mentioned in the news are almost invariably young, their names accompanied by “eighteen year old” or “nineteen year old.”) Fantastic–let’s bomb lots of Palestinian buildings and move in the troops!

One of the things that bothers me the most is how clearly our media is villifying the Palestinians and taking great pains to make the Israeli army look like a bunch of swell guys. Every report I’ve heard (except on NPR, of course) makes sure we know that the Israeli army is hitting empty targets at night, taking care not to “unneccessarily kill cilivians.” Naturally this makes me wonder what would qualify as necessarily killing civilians, but I don’t suppose that report will be forthcoming.

Frustrated and wishing I knew more, I asked my sig fig why the US continues to support Israel without question. One part of her answer was that Israel has been a traditional “stronghold of democracy in the middle east,” which the US feels an obligation to support it. I suppose this makes sense–if we’re going to run around “nation-building” and “liberating” and all, supposedly fostering democracy and bringing light to previously dark dictatorships, we can hardly leave our democratic buddies hanging, much less criticize anything they do. So instead we sit back, make vague comments about how Palestine should really try some diplomacy, and generally do nothing.

Here’s my problem with this: the current state of Israel cannot be considered a stronghold for democracy. Not under the traditional definition, anyway, which as I understand it includes equality as a major tenent. (Ignore, for now, that democratic political structures and capitalist economic structures aren’t meant to coexist, since one promotes theoretical equality while the other relies on unequal distrubution of wealth.) The occupation of Palestinian land does not make Israelis and Palestinians equal citizens. That would be like saying Iraqis and Americans are equals.

Oh, but I shouldn’t make that comparison. After all, the clearly wronged Israeli army is bombing empty targets, while American soldiers like to rape and murder Iraqi civilians. Totally different situation.

Advertisements

3 Responses to The situation in Israel.

  1. sig fig who is unpolitical says:

    Hoooo baby, do I have some boring books about the American Revolution for you. Our particular democracy wasn’t really founded on the purest ideals. It was founded by a bunch of merchants and plantation owners who wanted to protect their wealth. So American-flavored democracy has capitalism, or something like it built right in.

    There are a bunch of definitions for democracy, but the US is really the main product developer. So unless you want to talk about the commune I’m peripherally involved in, democracy and capitalism are entangled in one slimy makeout session.

  2. sig fig who just threw up a little in her mouth says:

    Yah. But a government needs to exist with some kind of economy. Is there something more fitting than capitalism to go along with democracy?

    I’m making myself puke with this. Let’s never talk about this again.

  3. pandanose says:

    I wasn’t saying that democracy and capitalism Don’t coexist; I was saying that, fundamentally, they aren’t really meant to, not if you want either one to stay true to its ideals. And yes, I’m well aware that neither our founding nor our current state of democracy is a great reflection of those ideals, but somehow we still manage to convince ourselves (and other countries) that our international actions are based on our loyalty to the ideals upon which we were supposedly founded.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: